The Thumbnail Strategy
đŻ Winning Meta Ads Before They Even Play
Howdy Readers đĽ°
In this newsletter, youâll find:
đŻ The Thumbnail Strategy: Winning Meta Ads Before They Even Play
đ Threads Drives 73.6% More Engagement Than X â What You Need to Know
đTweet of the Day
If youâre new to Buyology then a hearty welcome to you, Youâve reached the right place alongside 50k+ amazing people, Before you forget, if someone forwarded this newsletter to you, don't forget to subscribe to our newsletter so you never miss out!
Together with Smart Recognition
𤯠New AI Lead Gen Tool Identifies Email Address of Your Visitors
What if we told you that you can Identify the email addresses of your anonymous website traffic?
A new AI-powered tool, Smart Recognition, has created the next evolution in lead generation.
Rather than getting only 5% of your traffic via an opt-in form, you can now target and email most of your website traffic, growing your email list and revenue faster!
Here are just some examples of how you can use this:
Capture the email addresses of up to 40% of your anonymous website Traffic.
Email an irresistible offer to prospects browsing your site.
Send abandoned cart emails to people who don't complete checkout.
Add those email addresses to Meta remarketing audiences.
Curious to see how much of your anonymous website traffic you can identify? Book a free demo & Get Started with Smart Recognition!
đŻ The Thumbnail Strategy: Winning Meta Ads Before They Even Play
The Battle is Won Before the First Frame Most advertisers obsess over video length, CTAs, and messaging, but the truth is, your ad is decided in a fraction of a secondâbefore the play button is even pressed. Metaâs auction system prioritizes engagement, and if your ad fails to hook attention immediately, your CPMs will soar while conversions plummet.
The real first impression isnât your copy or offerâitâs your thumbnail. And yet, most brands donât test it. They focus on video edits when, in reality, the best-performing videos often win or lose based on their preview image alone.
Why Thumbnails Matter More Than You Think
Meta treats engagement signals as real-time quality indicators. If your ad fails to generate interaction within the first second, it gets deprioritized in the auction. Thatâs why ads with a scroll-stopping thumbnail outperform even well-scripted videos. Think of your ad like a YouTube videoâif no one clicks, it doesnât matter how good the content is.
Instead of testing five different videos, test five different thumbnails first. Once you find the one that drives the highest initial engagement, apply it to your best creative.
The Perfect Thumbnail: What Actually Works?
Thumbnails should stop the scroll instantly. The best-performing ones tend to:
Feature human faces with strong emotional expressions (joy, surprise, curiosity).
Use high-contrast colors and bold text overlays to pop in the feed.
Show the product in action (not just a static image).
Create tension or curiosity (so people feel compelled to click).
The key is testing thumbnails first, then creativesânot the other way around.
Smarter Approach: The 72-Hour Thumbnail Test
1ď¸âŁ Launch thumbnail-only tests (without video) to analyze which preview image gets the highest CTR and engagement.
2ď¸âŁ Apply the winning thumbnail to your actual video ads.
3ď¸âŁ Monitor performance for 72 hoursâkeep scaling winners and kill the rest.
đ Final Takeaway: Your adâs first impression is the only impression that matters. If you donât test your thumbnail first, youâre setting up your best creative to fail. The brands that master pre-click engagement will dominate Meta in 2025.
đ Threads Drives 73.6% More Engagement Than X â What You Need to Know
Insights from Buffer
A study analyzing 10.2 million posts from Threads and X in 2024 reveals that Threads generates 73.6% higher engagement rates, making it a strong platform for audience interaction. But with X still leading in monthly active users, a cross-posting strategy might be the best approach.
The Breakdown
đš Threads Wins on Engagement: Threads posts achieved a 6.25% median engagement rate, compared to 3.6% on X, highlighting stronger audience interactions. Lower platform saturation and engagement-driven algorithms help posts gain visibility and traction.
đš Why Threads Stands Out: Threads benefits from Instagram integration, less competition, and a community-driven experience, encouraging discussions rather than passive content consumption. Its algorithm favors likes, replies, and shares, increasing visibility in the For You feed.
đš X Remains Stable for High-Impact Content: Despite lower engagement rates, X maintains a large active user base, making it ideal for concise, real-time updates. While Threads peaked in engagement in November 2024, X remains valuable for news, industry insights, and viral moments.
đš Cross-Posting Maximizes Reach: With Threads excelling in engagement and X offering wider exposure, creators and brands should leverage both for optimal reach. Posting tailored content across platforms ensures better visibility without over-reliance on a single channel.
Social platforms are evolving, and understanding where engagement thrives helps brands and creators make smarter content decisions. With Threads rising and X holding steady, a hybrid strategy may be key to long-term success.
đTweet of the Day
Advertise with Us
Wanna put out your message in front of over 50,000 best marketers and decision makers?
Checkout our Partner Kit heređ¤
At Buyology, we care about our readers and want to provide the best possible experience. That's why we always look for ways to improve our content and connect with our audience. It would be amazing if you could hit us up with feedback about our content or absolutely anything, we are always up for a chat đĽ°
Thanks for your support, We'll be back with more such content đĽł